Wednesday, October 8, 2014

Water, Water Everywhere

Nor Any Drop to Drink
Presentation to city council 9/18
Please understand that I do not enjoy making these presentations One reason is that I am not very good at it. Having said that, I am a data freak and when I come across information that may be helpful to the city I feel obligated to share it with council and the public. My intent is to be non confrontational and to offer constructive ideas.

The subject at hand is a case in point.
During the debate on the need to increase water department revenue and quotes from a paid consultant about how to do so, I heard not one word about about the 130 million gallon gorilla in the closet.

Yes I30 million gallons of treated water per year has gone missing. This loss is equal to a football field sized pool 30 feet deep.

After several days of searching the public record and talking with utility billing and water department personnel I collected the following historical data for 2013.

Revised numbers:
Data and source:
From the water department: millions gallons (MG) of treated water delivered 557.5
From utility billing office – treated water sold: MG 396.8.
Difference between delivered and sold: 160.7
From the water department: MG used in the plant: 27.1*
From the utility billing department:
Waste water plant use, metered but not charged MG 1.5
City Building use, metered but not charged MG .33
My estimate of other city buildings used but not charged MG .8 (probably high)
My estimate of un-metered uncharged legitimate uses including fire hydrant flush, fire suppression, sprinkler tests: MG 1.0
All other non metered - not accounted for MG 130
* Treated water is used in the treatment process
Some leakage is to be expected but In my uneducated opinion a 24% loss rate is more than just excessive.
a. The loss represents thousands of dollars per year in wasted treatment costs. The market value is over $700,000.
b. This information needs to be confirmed and if it is found to be valid, action should be taken as outlined in the included internet link.

We are actually wasting 162 thousand pounds of lime, 71 thousand pounds of alum, 24 thousand pounds of CO2 and ten thousand pounds of other chemicals including, charcoal, phosphate and chlorine into this lost asset. 7 million gallons of treated water used in the treatment process is also lost. We might as well be taking the material directly to the landfill. Shouldn’t this gross waste be pursued as ardently as seeking new revenue?

I do hope that the Fife Ave. work will help to reduce a little of the loss but I wonder what took us so long.
Paul Hunter budhunter@frontier.com


WATER AUDITS AND WATER LOSS CONTROL FOR PUBLIC WATER SYSTEMS

1. The average water loss in public water systems is 16%. Up to 75% of the loss is recoverable.
2. Authorized consumption is the sum of billed and unbilled metered consumption.
3. Unauthorized consumption is unmetered and unbilled consumption caused by theft.

4. Leakage and other unmetered consumption such as fire department activities can account for a significant amount of unbilled consumption

No comments:

Post a Comment